Here's all the albums from 2005 I've heard so far, ranked and such:

I LOVE . . .

ALLIGATOR - The National

I REALLY LIKE . . .

BLACK SHEEP BOY - Okkervil River
EP - Fiery Furnaces
ILLINOIS - Sufjan Stevens

I LIKE . . .

IN CASE WE DIE - Architecture in Helsinki
CLAP YOUR HANDS SAY YEAH - Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
HORSES IN THE SKY - A Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchestra & Tra La La Band*
FACE THE TRUTH - Stephen Malkmus
THE WOODS - Sleater-Kinney
FLIES THE FIELDS - Shipping News
NATURALLY - Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings
TOUCHPOOL - L. Pierre
BANG BANG ROCK & ROLL - Art Brut

I'm MIXED on . . .

WORLDS APART - ...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead
THE GREAT DESTROYER - Low
SOME CITIES - Doves

I DON'T LIKE . . .

WITH TEETH - Nine Inch Nails
GUERO - Beck

*If the second half was as amazing as the first, this would be the album of the year. But alas . . .